John William Colenso’s Collection of Psalms and Hymns for St Peter’s Cathedral, Pietermaritzburg: Context, Analysis and Christological Implications

In 1866, Bishop John William Colenso published a collection of hymns which he compiled for use at St Peter’s Cathedral in Pietermaritzburg. He had recently returned to Natal from England after defending himself the legal debates surrounded his status as Natal. His controversial commentaries on Romans and Pentateuch been catalyst denouncement by metropolitan bishop, Robert Gray. While England, Gray visited Diocese there, introduced Hymns Ancient Modern parish churches. was strong critic Modern, mainly account its ritualist tendencies, annoyed find that book absence. response, created hymns, number edited order conform evolving Christology. The sparked something media frenzy both Britain, so much it still being discussed four years Colenso’s death. This article provides historical context subsequent revisions; an analysis contents, paying special attention were modified some way; critique letters reviews received press. suggests notoriety ensured far more than warranted. essence, served proxy battle ground deeper concerns about impact biblical criticism